As Israel prepares to hold crucial legislative elections, the deadly October 7 attacks that took place more than three years ago remain a source of pain – and a hot-button political issue.
The Jewish people’s experience on October 7 was the most horrendous national trauma since the Holocaust. And the trauma continues – with the ongoing war launched by Benjamin Netanyahu’s right-wing government against Gaza, public anger over the lengthy time is took to secure the release of hostages taken during the Hamas-led attacks, and the domestic political turmoil that is on full display going into crucial elections on October 27 that could oust Netanyahu from power.
This all conflicts with the concept of “going on being,” which prominent British psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott argued was the anchor of a child’s present and future. Prolonged and massive trauma of the type seen in Israel since the October attacks can be described as a state of “going off being.”
By this, I refer to a chronic traumatic environment where the stable conditions necessary to process and cope with trauma as a “discrete, single event” simply do not exist.
Within this reality, Israeli therapists are tasked with absorbing and treating extreme trauma while simultaneously navigating their own grief and shock as citizens of a fractured society experiencing deep political upheaval.
As a psychoanalyst and a co-founder of First Line Med – an organization established on the morning of October 7, 2023 – I can attest to the profound relief that psychoanalytic therapy has brought to hundreds of survivors, bereaved families, families of hostages, and individuals released from captivity in Gaza.
More than 450 psychoanalysts volunteered to provide long-term, pro-bono psychoanalytic therapy to these survivors. We believe that providing long-term care, free of charge, plays a vital role in restoring survivors’ faith and trust in the existence of “good objects,” both external and internal.
Following three years of dedicated clinical work on the front lines, we have gathered critical insight into what is required on this arduous journey of learning to live with catastrophic trauma.
A “good enough” setting: We define this as the most adaptive and supportive framework for engaging with survivors at any given phase of their recovery. For a long time, this required massive clinical flexibility.
Many survivors were treated in the lobbies of the hotels where they had been evacuated, at their bedsides in hospitals, or in temporary living rooms. We bent traditional frame parameters to meet the survivors’ immediate psychological needs.
This effort was bolstered by over 100 volunteer psychiatrists who frequently conducted home visits when survivors found it impossible to be outside.
Following the patient’s own pace: Psychoanalytic therapy, unlike behavioral-cognitive “models” focuses on the patient’s internal well-being, as opposed to “organizing” the patient and focusing on his or her “functioning”.
This is not to say that the latter two are not important, but rather that they are defined as the “end results” of an internal change and not as the main goals of the therapeutic interventions.
This core value of psychoanalysis implies long-term therapy and the therapist’s conscious attention to various areas of “functioning,” meaning the “emotional” and the “internal” take precedence over the “external” and the “behavioral”.
The intersection of psychoanalysis and socio-political activism: Prior to the October 7 massacre, the majority of Israeli psychoanalysts were actively engaged in the struggle for Israeli democracy. In the wake of the attack, they stepped out of their private offices and moved past traditional analytical “neutrality,” adopting an active role in sowing hope across the scorched earth left behind by Hamas.
Israeli psychoanalyst Yolanda Gampel in 2021, at the height of the COVID, coined the metaphor of “the falling wall” to describe social traumas where the patient and therapist share the exact same catastrophic reality. This occurred during the pandemic, and it defines the aftermath of the October 7 massacre.
Psychoanalysts, like all Israeli citizens, have had to endure the longest war in the country’s history, facing thousands of missile attacks targeting civilian areas day and night. Therapists spent sleepless nights in bomb shelters, worried for their loved ones, and were exposed to the most horrific details of the atrocities with little to no external structural support.
Operating under a shared trauma fundamentally challenges classic therapeutic neutrality and inherently deepens mutual identification.
The preservation of hope, faith, and trust: October 7 shattered two of Israel’s most fundamental collective assumptions: first, that following the Holocaust, the Jewish people had permanently ensured “Never Again”; and second, that the Israeli Defense Forces are an invincible shield that will always protect its citizens.
Both core beliefs collapsed – the unthinkable happened, and help did not arrive in time. While all severe traumas shatter a survivor’s basic assumptions, a catastrophe of this magnitude causes a total rupture.
People felt betrayed by the state apparatus and were left shocked. A core pillar of our psychoanalytic mission has been to repair and restore the survivors’ belief in their good internal objects.
Remarkably, many individuals, especially the hostages, did this intuitively. Upon returning from captivity, many spoke in media interviews about how they survived starvation, isolation, and torture. Crucially, their survival anchored on an ethical commitment to the well-being of others – whether caring for fellow captives or holding onto the memory of the families they left behind.
What kept them human and sane was an unyielding attachment to their internal good object, alongside their willingness to serve as a good object for someone else.
It is an impossible task to fully summarize three consecutive years of treating mass trauma born from some of the most horrific atrocities witnessed in the modern Western world. However, if forced to distill our experience, I must emphasize the unwavering importance of human solidarity and compassionate psychoanalytic activism.
Neutrality must never be equated with silence. Psychoanalysis and its practitioners must take an active ethical stance when innocent people are abused and terrorized. In times of severe political turmoil and cruelty, true solidarity means actively restoring the presence of the “good object.” No one should ever be left to carry the weight of catastrophic trauma alone. No one.